DVD : P.S. I Love You

- Absolutely Beautiful
After being in her shoes I think this movie is beautiful. Hilary did a great job of portraying the emotions that one goes through and did so beautifully. Life goes on around you, but you have to make the choice to step out onto the sidewalk.

Rating:

- ITS LIKE KISSING MY SISTER!!!!!!
Yea, cant really believe people are giving this 4 stars on average. I do agree Hillary Swank did a overall great job as well as Harry Jr. as the side character. Actually I would of given this movie 4 out of 5 if not for one scene in which I think ruins the movie.
The whole "You kiss like my sister" and "oh I'm glad you think so to" scene. "oh lets be friends" Yea horribly acted and totally unrealistic. Besides the whole way he says it justs gives me the creeps and a few laughs since. I know his character is brash but come on. Could of done that scene a thousand other ways....ok ok this is based on book which I have not read, and based on that scene I surely wont be reading. I guess overall good movie but when you see the scene with Yankee stadium....turn off the sound for about 3 min. Then I imagine it could be a satisfying movie.

Rating:

- Better than the book.
I normally DO NOT say that a movie is better than the book, but sadly, in this case it's true. Yes, you get more background on the characters, but for me, the book was boring. The movie was more fast paced and didn't include anything dull.

Rating:

- P. S. I Love You 2007
Three stars for the movie itself, four stars because the cast is so charming. I would add another star if only Gerard Butler had been on screen more.

page 1 of 32
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11